Chicago Is My Kind Of Town by Luke Radl
We've Got Your Summer Reading

Republication Without Compensation

Daily newspaper Al Nas (Iraq) publishes a daily cartoon from our website, without telling us.

Cartoon Movement has a simple objective: to promote professional editorial cartooning and comics journalism by publishing high quality cartoons and comics for a global audience. What sets our platform apart is that we pay cartoonists for the work they publish with us. When we started Cartoon Movement one-and-a-half years ago, we anticipated that reselling cartoons to other media would be one of our main sources of revenue. We have built what we feel is an impressive client list including the Guardian, the New Internationalist and Amnesty International (Denmark).

We also anticipated that we would have to be vigilant with regard to our content being used elsewhere on the Web without us knowing about it. From the outset we decided we did not mind people sharing our cartoons on their blogs or on Facebook (what we define as personal, non-commercial use in our FAQ), but that we wouldn't allow companies or organizations to use our content for free.

In most instances when our content is reposted without our permission by another commercial organization, no credit or link to our site is provided, making it difficult to find. Our network of cartoonists has proved invaluable in tracking where our content is used, keeping  an eye out in their respective countries. But as our site grows, so does the unauthorized use of our content, and the tools available to fight it are meagre.

This weekend, Iraqi cartoonist Saad Murthada informed me he had seen one of my cartoons in Al Nas, a daily newspaper in Baghdad. After some investigation, it turned out that Al Nas has been publishing a daily cartoon from Cartoon Movement for at least the last two months. We publish cartoons at 800 X 560 pixels, which is not sufficient for print, but is apparently good enough for this publication.

In a case like this, our options are limited. Realistically, the only option we have is to write a polite letter asking them to stop (which we have done), and offering them a subscription so that they can use our content for a certain monthly fee. If they decide to ignore us, there is not much else we can do. As a small organization, we lack the time and resources to pursue any form of legal action.

Our experiences  with online and offline media using our content without our permission are reasonable good for the most part; often they will apologize and pay our invoice without protest. Some have even made this (dubious) process into official policy: L'Espresso in Italy often posts cartoon slideshows taken from various websites, only paying a republication fee when the website(s) in question find out about the use of their content.

In some cases the organizations in question will just ignore our pleas, and continue to publish our content without any reference to us. The most blatant example of this is ToonsOnline, a website that steals cartoons from artists around the world. They have even put '© All Rights Reserved' on the bottom of their website. I'm not sure about their business model, but I do know they’ve managed to build quite a fan base over the backs of hard-working artists. Another example is, a site that publishes a cartoon daily. They make money with advertising, and have published our cartoons without our permission on more than one occasion. I sent them several messages, but have yet to hear back.

I have no doubt Cartoon Movement will survive, and I have no doubt this practice will continue, but it is sometimes frustrating not to be able to take decisive action against it.

Tjeerd Royaards


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Menekse Cam

The using without permission is really annoying! Maybe a watermark on all the cartoons published in Cartoon Movement would be a solution for this.

Elias Tabakeas

Yes it is a terrible situation… And yeah I was wondering about “ToonsOnLine” that I stumbled upon one day that I was googling my name…
Actually I am not that surprised because in Greece some newspaper and magazine publishers, using the current crisis as an alibi, use this terrible method of “see this great cartoon published at x … or uploaded at y” (sometimes without even the reference) rather than paying professional cartoonists to do cartoons for them… with the result a substantial proportion of us being unemployed…
As to the solution… no, watermarks are ugly… but perhaps one of those systems that prohibits the use of the mouse right- click (thus the ability to save the file)… I do not know how it is done but in my researches for photos for my cartoons I come across this sometimes…

Tjeerd Royaards

I don't like watermarks either. Hindering the right-click action (with a swap-over copyright notice) is a possibility, although I think the savvy picture-snatcher will just take a screenshot of the page and cut out the cartoon. It is a good way to show people that copyright is a serious issue. The US association of cartoonists has a copyright notice that appears when you hover over the cartoon with your mouse:

Would that be a good option?


Muito bom


It's a shame that some people just disrespect artists in this way. I publish cartoons in my blog and unffortunetly I saw a lot of pages and sites stealing someone's material, include mine. But we must continue working hard to change this situation.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)